Posted on June 14, 2021
Among the many terms that arise in connection with Medicaid planning is the concept of Estate Recovery, which is the process by which the government recoups part of the Medicaid benefits paid on behalf of a Medicaid applicant during his or her lifetime.
Under the Medicaid or Medical Assistance (MA) program in all states, in order to qualify, clients must expend or otherwise divest their countable assets until those assets are not more than a (very low) level permitted under the laws of the state in which the clients are living.
Depending on the specific manner in which an applicant’s assets are spent down or divested, an applicant may also be ineligible for MA for an additional period of time after their assets reach the permitted level. Certain assets are, however, considered exempt (or non-countable) and are therefore not counted toward an individual’s eligibility during his or her lifetime. For many people, the most significant exempt asset is their home. Subject to certain requirements, an applicant’s (and/or spouse’s) interest in a primary residence is ordinarily not counted toward the applicant’s MA eligibility.
Under the Estate Recovery program in most states, the government agency charged with administering MA benefits (the Department of Human Service or DHS in Pennsylvania) will normally have a claim against a decedent’s estate equal to the amount of MA benefits paid on behalf of a deceased MA applicant during his or her lifetime.
Insofar as the home is an asset of the decedent’s estate, the home will be subject to the government’s “Estate Recovery” claim, i.e., its claim for reimbursement of skilled nursing care costs paid during the deceased applicant’s lifetime. For that reason, it is perhaps more accurate to view the exemption as a deferral of (rather than an exemption from) a family’s obligation to expend its own assets to pay for the applicant’s skilled nursing care. Because the home is one of the few assets not counted toward an applicant’s MA eligibility, it is the asset most likely to ultimately be subject to Estate Recovery.
In some states, Estate Recovery is expansively applied to reach assets besides those in the decedent’s probate estate (i.e., assets titled in the decedent’s name and which are subject to administration as part of his or her estate). However, in many states, including Pennsylvania, Estate Recovery is limited to the decedent’s (probate) estate.
For example, a home titled solely in the deceased MA recipient’s individual name ordinarily will be subject to Estate Recovery, whereas a home titled in the name of his or her spouse (or jointly with his or her spouse as husband and wife) will normally not be subject to Estate Recovery.
Estate Recovery also places responsibility (and potential legal exposure) for payment on the person(s) administering the decedent’s estate (such as an Executor). An Executor is responsible for inquiring with the applicable government agency to find out whether a decedent received MA benefits during his or her lifetime that give rise to an Estate Recovery Claim against the estate.
The government then has a finite period of time (45 days in Pennsylvania) to respond by notifying the Executor of the existence and extent of any such claims against the decedent’s estate. If an Executor disregards or fails to make a proper inquiry about Estate Recovery and therefore fails to pay an Estate Recovery claim against the estate, the Executor can be held personally responsible for payment. The potential for Estate Recovery is yet another reason why most Executors are well advised to seek legal counsel in administering an estate.
There are certain exceptions to an estate’s obligation for Estate Recovery, including in cases where imposition of the Estate Recovery would cause undue hardship to beneficiaries of the estate or other persons. However, such exceptions are generally subject to various requirements and are normally narrowly construed. Also, the burden of proving that all of the requirements are met falls upon the person(s) seeking the waiver.
Jeff Scibetta focuses his practice on elder law planning, complex estate planning and administration, business planning, succession planning, tax planning, and real estate. He has spoken to a variety of groups and professionals about elder law matters.